“Bad Blood”

(Brenton’s Version)

The original budget the county executive handed to county council: JES Presents – Making Sense of Erie County Residents’ Dollars and Cents

Brenton’s Version (aka Brenton’s Spin): County Executive Davis Announces 2025 Budget Vetoes

A few takeaways–

He says that his economic development department is not a duplication of effort, despite the fact that there are a number of organizations in Erie County that are committed to economic development.

He says that the Human Resource Commission IS a duplication of effort, because Erie County residents can travel to Pittsburgh or Harrisburg, but he offers no solutions for transportation to Pittsburgh or Harrisburg. Not only that, but he gave the library collaboratory rooms to Gannon in the lease. People attempting to make Zoom calls instead of traveling will have no quiet space in which to do so.

He claims he doesn’t want to raise taxes. He raised them by 10.6% last year, and it didn’t seem to both him then. It seems like he’s running a re-election campaign instead of the county.

He insists he needs $2.5 million for an EMS authority to protect our “friends and neighbors.” $1.5 million in ARPA funds were given to Gannon for Project NepTWNE. There is no plan for this $2.5 million. It seems that some “friends and neighbors” are more important than others. A budget is a plan for spending. Seeing the budget for 2025 and how he can hand such a large chunk of money to Gannon, can anyone be confident in his planning skills for EMS?

He sees no issue in taking money from the reserve that was committed to the Erie County Community College. If he were allowed to do that (which he isn’t), it would force the taxpayers to then support ECCC if the fund is depleted.

He disagrees with council’s cutting the communications officer’s position because it’s become too political. During the snow emergency–when people need information–there were no updates to the county website. In fact, it hasn’t been updated since before the election.

One of the contentions of our lawsuit is that the country executive breeched his fiduciary duty to the taxpayers of Erie County. I guess you can say that he’s consistent.

Here’s a list of meetings for Thursday, December 5 Erie County PA:
3:30 Board of Elections Meeting
4:00 Erie County Council Finance and Personnel meeting
This meeting is for items on the agenda for the regular council meeting 12/10/24
5:00 Erie County Council Special Meeting on the budget (to consider overriding the vetoes)

Please attend if you can, or offer input to council: Stay Engaged.

“Now we got problems and I don’t think we can solve them.”

~Taylor Swift

Black Friday Was A Bust, but We’ve Got You Covered!

Were your Black Friday shopping plans cancelled due to the Snowmageddongiving we’re experiencing? Don’t worry! We’ve got you covered! If you are looking for the perfect gift and want to support a great cause at the same time, look no further than our KOLPon fundraiser! There are also links on the main page of our website. For $25, buy one plate and get a second plate of an equal or lesser value for free at Julius Restaurant. Proceeds go to our legal fund. Thank you to Julio Reyes for always being such a dedicated supporter of KOLP! We are grateful to have him as a friend.

So not only do you have Black Friday covered, you have Small Business Saturday, Cyber Monday, and Giving Tuesday covered as well.

“Gratitude can turn a meal into a feast.”

~Melody Beattie

Thanks for Giving, Dr. Blasco!

As we celebrate Thanksgiving tomorrow, it’s important for us to remember to be thankful for what we have. Erie County residents can be especially thankful for the Blasco Erie County Library. This is why we are fighting so hard to keep the entire library open to the public: Keep Our Library Public in Erie PA.

“The whole purpose of education is to turn mirrors into windows.”

~Sydney J. Harris

Public Left In the Dark: Where Has All that Money Gone, Besides to Gannon?

Although the “underfunded amount” is fluid, this amount was estimated on Nov. 21 going into the 2 P.M. Erie County Council Caucus prior to the final budget vote. The exact amount of funds is yet to be determined.

Davis’ budget was presented on October 1 to county council and available on-line for the public. It was riddled with errors, inaccuracies and is a downright conundrum for anyone’s comprehension, including veteran accountants with 40-year familiarity with previously balanced Erie County budgets: JES Presentation.

Citizens feel a keen sense of abuse and horror that since Davis has been at the helm, Erie County budgets have not added up. Top heavy administration expenses, back door salary increases and defiant, uncooperative management has led to marathon inquiry for information Davis has held in contempt of transparency.

As citizens, we must demand independent 3rd party audits of Erie County budgets for transparency and a realistic assessment of how our tax dollars have been budgeted and spent.

“A lack of transparency results in distrust and a deep sense of insecurity.”

~Dalai Lama

The Math Ain’t Mathing, Folks!

One of our contentions in our lawsuit against the county executive is that the lease with Gannon breached his fiduciary duty to the taxpayers of Erie County. In keeping with that pattern, his proposed 2025 is, well, I don’t think I can say it better than Erie County Council: Erie County Council: Davis’ budget has $700,000 of extra deficits. And while the county executive is politicizing public safety by making claims on his re-election Facebook page that council is refusing to fund a county EMS authority, it was revealed during today’s (November 19th) budget hearing that EMS and municipal GAP funding was authorized in 2024, but the county executive didn’t utilize those funds. Most of the funds still remain the account! November 19, 2024 County Council Second Public Budget Hearing (1:12:45). There was also discussion about ARPA funds and how they are to be use for people that truly need the funds. Don’t forget that the county executive made sure that Project NepTWNE received $1.5 million, however–just $1 million less than he has budgeted for the EMS authority. You can learn more about the budget at the Jefferson Educational Society tomorrow (November 20th): Making Sense of Erie County Residents’ Dollars and Cents

This pattern of behavior is why we are suing to dissolve the lease of Blasco Library. For the good of Erie County, this lack of fiscal irresponsibility can’t be allowed to continue.

“The essence of math is not to make simple things complicated, but to make complicated things simple.”
~Stan Gudder

Priorities, Part 2

The past couple of weeks have been quite harrowing for the firefighters in our area due to drought conditions and high winds. These men and women are true hometown heroes and give so much of their time and energy to keep us safe. Please support our local volunteer fire companies! The county executive has issued a burning ban and said how important the volunteer fire companies are during his photo ops. However, actions speak louder than words. Let’s compare what the local public service entities received in ARPA funds vs what Project NepTWNE received.

American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds were designed to help the country recover from the effects of the pandemic. For more information on how ARPA grants were to be distributed and the qualifications: State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds. Project NepTWNE was granted $1.5 million in ARPA funds to build a water research lab in the Union Fish Building as the ordinance was written: https://keepourlibrarypublic.com/faqs/#erie-county-documents-regarding-the-1-5-million-grant-to-gannon. Keep in mind these funds were granted to a private, religious university with a large endowment. Gannon still had remote classes during the pandemic: Gannon to pay $1.1 million to settle class-action suit over COVID-era remote instruction.

As is shown in the comparison, most of the fire departments were given less than 1% of what was given to Gannon, which at the end of the 2022 school year had an endowment of $71 million. And Gannon got a lease of the taxpayer funded library on top of it? And the county executive wants to take over the 911 system when he feels that a private university deserves more funding than our local volunteer firefighters? This is why we need to hold him accountable when it comes to taxpayer money!

“They say in every library there is a single book that can answer the question that burns like a fire in the mind.”

~Lemony Snicket

Are You a Responsible Employer?

“Wait! What? Me? I’m not an employer!” you may be saying. But as a taxpayer and citizen you are. There has been a lot said lately that if you don’t like the job an elected official is doing, then vote them out. Voting is extremely important—and I hope you exercise your franchise on Tuesday–that’s not enough, however. A lot of damage can be done in four years. Think about the amount of damage a toddler can do in four years—and yes, that’s a very deliberate comparison—let alone someone that has access to millions of dollars in funds and assets. If the country executive is not leveraging taxpayer assets—such as farmland or a library—in a way that is beneficial to taxpayers and citizens, then taxpayers need to give feedback—just as a good employer would. That’s why it’s so important to stay engaged.
The county executive is calling the Human Relations Commission a duplication of effort and telling citizens that they need to travel to Pittsburgh or Harrisburg to get assistance. What if they don’t have transportation? What if they aren’t familiar with Pittsburgh driving? It’s not for the faint of heart. The irony here is that Gannon officials argued at their “public input sessions” that Blasco Library was a better location for Project NepTWNE than the Tom Ridge Environmental Center (TREC) because it was too hard to get transportation to TREC, but TREC is still in the same city and not 2-4 hours away. Why the concern for convenience for a so-called tourist attraction, but not for basic services?
The 2025 budget is so far out of wack that the county executive is simply taking millions of dollars from the reserve fund. That’s the rainy day fund. If it looks like rain, it’s only because he’s seeding the clouds. This is so that he can blame council if a tax hike or cuts are needed.
He is eliminating 74 positions with the excuse that these positions aren’t filled. Why aren’t they filled? Why is there such turnover in his administration?
Elected officials serve at the pleasure of the taxpayers. Yes, vote, but in the meantime, between elections, let officials know your opinions and if necessary, take legal action if there are no other remedies, such as the KOLP lawsuit. Be a responsible employer. Protect county funds and assets, and make sure they work for the taxpayers, not the county executive.

“With great power comes great responsibility.”

~Uncle Ben, Spiderman

Priorities

One of the “highlights” of the county executive on his countywide budget tour is how the allocation of ARPA funds are helping the municipalities of Erie county fund infrastructure projects that they otherwise couldn’t fund. Although there are other allocations of ARPA money, let’s compare the municipal funds with what was given to Gannon University for Project NepTWNE ($1.5 million), since the municipalities are where the county executive purports to prioritize. The source is here: Erie County, Pa. has spent roughly $41 million in ARPA funds. Where did the funds go?

American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds were designed to help the country recover from the effects of the pandemic. For more information on how ARPA grants were to be distributed and the qualifications: State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds. Project NepTWNE was granted $1.5 million in ARPA funds to build a water research lab in the Union Fish Building as the ordinance was written: https://keepourlibrarypublic.com/faqs/#erie-county-documents-regarding-the-1-5-million-grant-to-gannon. Keep in mind these funds were granted to a private, religious university with a large endowment. Gannon still had remote classes during the pandemic: Gannon to pay $1.1 million to settle class-action suit over COVID-era remote instruction.

As is shown in the comparison, each of these municipalities received a fraction of what was given to Gannon, which at the end of the 2022 school year had an endowment of $71 million. If, as the county executive contends, these municipalities are so desperate for money for basic services, then why was one of the largest chunks of it given to an entity that wasn’t so desperate? And then Gannon got a lease of the taxpayer funded library on top of it? You might also want to check the article for public safety grants and how those were prioritized considering the country executive has ideas about the county 911 system.

“Fairness does not mean everyone gets the same. Fairness means everyone gets what they need.”

~Rick Riordan

S-BOOK-TACULAR Sale

Support the Friends of the Library! The S-BOOKTACULAR Sale is from Thursday, Oct. 17 through Saturday, Oct. 19, 2024 at Blasco Library. Also, at the Bayfront Bookshelf, all Stephen King and Anne Rice titles are on sale through October 28! Make sure you visit the library itself while you are there and keep those numbers up!

And speaking scary things, make sure you review the proposed 2025 Erie County budget and bring any concerns you may have to your council rep.

“There is something at work in my soul, which I do not understand.”

~Mary Shelley, Frankenstein