Are You a Good Employer?, Part 2

Imagine repeatedly ending up in court because you refuse to follow the rules of your job. Erie County Council considers new lawsuit against Davis to thwart ‘illegal’ 2025 vetoes

And then when you lose, refusing to accept it. Sound familiar? Erie County Executive Davis appeals ruling that nullified his budget vetoes

You probably wouldn’t last at you job very long, would you? This year, we can be good employers and make sure the county executive isn’t in his job much longer by voting him out of a job. In the meantime, please help support the KOLP lawsuit, and hold the county executive accountable for his actions.

“Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.”
― Martin Luther King Jr.

Coincidence?

Some of you might remember that the Lettie G Howard was scheduled for removal from its dock space on May 17, 2024. Lettie G. Howard’s captain hopeful ship remains in Erie, Tall Ships gets more support

A Right to Know Request email with that same date was discovered discussing Project NepTWNE with Gannon professors and contracted architects.

I’ll let you draw your own conclusions.

“Don’t give up the ship.”

~Oliver Hazard Perry

Continuing to Stay Engaged

It was announced during City Council Meeting – January 8, 2025 that there would be a waiver of rules to fill vacant spots for appointments to the Higher Education Building Authority (HEBA), since Gannon needs a tax-exempt bond to be issued for an upcoming project, and they didn’t want to have their timeline held up due to lack of board members.

Under Treasury regulations, the role of the HEBA is to hold a public TEFRA (Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982) hearing about the project and the private activity tax-exempt bond being issued so the public has an opportunity to provide comment. HEBA must pass a resolution approving the financing to go through. No city funds are used. This is an IRS requirement for any nonprofit borrower providing a public benefit that is seeking tax-exempt bonds.

Here is the Notice of Public Hearing for this:

NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given of a public hearing to be held by the City of Erie Higher Education Building Authority (the “Authority”) on January 21, 2025 at 10:00 a.m. in the City Council Chambers on the first floor of the City of Erie Municipal Building, 626 State Street, Erie, PA, 16501. Individuals and representatives of organizations who desire to present oral testimony at the public hearing are requested to state their names at the public hearing and addresses as well as the organization they represent. The public hearing is in connection with a proposed plan of financing involving the issuance by the Authority of its tax-exempt revenue bonds (the “Bonds”) in one or more series pursuant to a plan of finance for the following project (the “Project”): A. BORROWER: Gannon University (the “University”), a Pennsylvania nonprofit corporation and a tax-exempt organization described in Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”) that is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(a) of the Code. B. MAXIMUM PRINCIPAL AMOUNT OF BONDS: $14,000,000 of which up to $2,500,000 will be applicable to the New Money Project (as defined below). C. DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT TO BE FINANCED: If issued, the Bonds are intended to be issued as qualified 501(c)(3) bonds described in Section 145 of the Code. The proceeds of the Bonds will be loaned to the University and used to finance, refinance or reimburse educational facilities, including all or a portion of the costs of a project that consists of: (1) the current refunding of all or a portion of the Authority’s Revenue Bonds (Gannon University Project) Series 2013 (the “2013 Bonds”), funding required reserves, and paying costs of issuing the Bonds; proceeds of the 2013 Bonds were used by the University, to finance the acquisition, design, construction, renovation, equipping and furnishing of new facilities and existing facilities of the University located on the main campus of the University (described below), including, but not limited to, renovation of the recreation center and construction of a field house and indoor turf field, together with certain site and infrastructure improvements and acquisition of capital equipment for use in or in connection with the University’s facilities; and (2) the payment of, or reimbursement to the University for (i) constructing, renovating, and/or equipping various facilities on its main campus (described below) in furtherance of its educational purposes; (ii) the funding of any required reserves and interest payable during construction; and (iii) the payment of certain costs of issuance of the Bonds (collectively, the “New Money Project”). D. LOCATION OF PROJECT: All facilities to be financed and/or refinanced are located at the Gannon University campus, which is located south of West 3rd Street, north of West 9th Street, east of Chestnut Street, and west of State Street, with the administrative office located at 109 University Square in the City of Erie, Erie County, Pennsylvania 16501. Immediately following the public hearing the Authority will convene a special meeting to take action on this project and any other matters that may be brought to the Authority’s attention. The public is invited to attend the hearing in person at the address set forth above. Members of the public may also submit written comments to the Authority for receipt in advance of the hearing by sending such comments c/o Jay W. Alberstadt, Jr., Esquire, MacDonald, Illig, Jones & Britton LLP, 100 State Street, Suite 700, Erie, PA 16507. This notice is published, and the public hearing is being held by and on behalf of the Authority as the issuer of the Bonds, as required by Section 147(f) of the Code, and regulations promulgated thereunder. CITY OF ERIE HIGHER EDUCATION BUILDING AUTHORITY.

It’s unclear what this project is, but considering a wavier of rules was requested, it might be a good idea to attend if you’re a city resident. The accelerated timeline is giving a sense of deja vu. Remember how important it is to stay engaged. The contact information for Erie City Council has been added to our Stay Engaged page.

“There is no power for change greater than a community discovering what it cares about.”

~Margaret J. Wheatley

The Waiting Game

If you are wondering why you haven’t seen more progression in the lawsuit, so are we. The county executive asked for an extension of the discovery period due to the “snow emergency,” and then missed the extended deadline. The funny thing is, this week he announced his re-election campaign. Correction, he announced that he would announce his re-election campaign, so he could get in an extra photo op. Is he running a campaign or running the county? He seems to have time for his campaign, but not time to respond to taxpayers.

Our case is strong. If the only strategy the county executive can employ in fighting the suit is his constant delay tactics, that speaks to our suit’s strength. After all, he has time to have a re-election announcement reception at $100 a plate. He should have the time to respond to deadlines. Keeping our library public actually deserves a donation. Every little bit counts to help fund our lawsuit while the county executive is busy playing his delaying games. Please help us hold the county executive accountable for his actions by making a donation at the link below.

“Patience is waiting. Not passively waiting. That is laziness. But to keep going when the going is hard and slow – that is patience. The two most powerful warriors are patience and time.”

~Leo Tolstoy

Davis is now 0 and 2

The county executive has settled a lawsuit with whistleblower Shawn Held who was fired after reporting on the food quality at the Edmund L. Thomas: Worker claimed Erie County executive fired him unjustly. Whistleblower lawsuit is settled. You might remember that last week a judge ruled that the county executive’s vetoes violated the Home Rule Charter: Judge rules that Brenton Davis budget vetoes violated Erie County law.

You can also access news articles via the NewsBank link on the Erie County Public Library website with your library card.

There seems to be a trend here. Let’s help continue it.

“The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”

~Martin Luther King, Jr.

Make a New Year’s Resolution

Make you new year’s resolution to spread the word! So many people either still haven’t heard about the lease of Blasco Library to Gannon University, or they assume that KOLP went away when Erie County failed to override the veto. Let people know that we are continuing our fight with our lawsuit!

How?

Happy New Year from KOLP! Here’s hoping that 2025 is a brighter year for Erie County!

“To build up a library is to create a life. It’s never just a random collection of books.”

Carlos María Domínguez

Your End of the Year Contribution

At the risk of sounding like someone on public radio, I’d like to remind you that the year is almost over, and so is your chance to make a contribution that can be deducted from your 2024 income tax. So there is no confusion, there is only one way to make your contribution tax deductible–donating to the EveryLibrary Institute–which is the first link button on our donate page. The other options are not tax deductible, but are very appreciated.

Remember, although the taxpayers of Erie County have already won one lawsuit to uphold the Home Rule Charter, we still await our day in court to Keep Our Library Public.

“The public library is a place where place and possibility meet.”

~Stuart Dybeck

Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus

On Monday, Senior Judge Edward Reibman ruled that the county executive violated the Home Rule Charter by issuing vetoes for the 2023 and 2024 budgets to increase spending Don’t forget, he did the same thing with the 2025 budget as well.

More information is available here: Judge rules that Brenton Davis budget vetoes violated Erie County law. Thank you to Erie County Council for filing this lawsuit to make sure the law was upheld!

If you would like to help fund our lawsuit to make sure the rule of law is upheld in the case of Blasco Library, please use the buttons below.

“The clearest way to show what the rule of law means to us in everyday life is to recall what happened when there is no rule of law.”

~President Dwight D. Eisenhower

Happy Jolabokaflod!

There’s a tradition in Iceland that dates back to World War II where imports were in short supply, but paper was available. Icelanders decided to give each other books on Christmas Eve and spend the evening reading, and they continue this tradition today. Jolabokaflod translates to “Christmas book flood,” and may sound like the perfect way to spend the holidays for many of us. If you want details on planning this for next year: Jolabokaflod: Iceland’s Christmas Reading Tradition Explained.

Happy Holidays from Keep Our Library Public!

Happy Festivus!

You may or may not remember the Festivus episode of Seinfield, depending on your age. After all, we aren’t just four old ladies! If you’re not familiar with it, you can read more about it here: Festivus. There are lots of Christmas stories, but let’s indulge in a Festivus story, and this one is about the recent early childhood ARPA funding. You may remember that the county executive recently vetoed $2.5 million in ARPA funding for child care. Erie County Council voted to override this veto with a 5-2 supermajority.

We’ll start with the airing of the grievances. The funds are to be administered by ECGRA (Erie County Gaming Revenue Authority) with ECGRA contributing matching funds. There are a couple of key points to note about the contract between ECGRA and the county, because the county executive apparently has some grievances. One, the county information officer must be notified when a grant is to be awarded. Note that ECGRA already makes it a practice that the county executive is notified. Maybe because the county executive is out of the office so much, he might not getting the messages. Two, there are now to be two checks issued for each grant…one from ECGRA and one from the county, so that taxpayers know that the county is involved. The checks that have previously been issued have both ECGRA and the county’s name on them. Does he really need his own check to hold? Is he trying to take credit for these grants? These are the same funds he VETOED! And, at least when there is one check, there is another entity checking the math. We’ve seen the relationship between the administration and math, and…yeah.

This contract was still being negotiated last week, with the deadline for appropriation of ARPA funds of December 31st rapidly approaching, and he’s quibbling about large checks for photo-ops?! That might be an indication of his priorities.

And now to feats of strength. This was won by Erie County Council and ECGRA. Thank you to Erie County Council for overriding the county executive’s veto by a 5-2 margin (with Bayle and Schauerman voting against). Thank you to ECGRA for being the adults in the room when this contract was negotiated. Both entities showed that the taxpayers and families are their priority, and showed great strength in their leadership.

And a final airing of the grievances for the taxpayers. Both when the $1.5 million in ARPA funding was granted to Gannon and when the lease in Blasco Library was announced, the county executive claimed how good Project NepTWNE would be for the future of our children. Yet, he vetoed $2.5 million in ARPA funds for those children for early child care. Let that sink in. Then he essentially hard-wires terms in a contract for those $2.5 million to get more photo-ops in a year where he is up for re-election. Let that sink in as well. Happy Festivus!

For more details: Brenton Davis contractually requires ECGRA to tout county’s involvement when awarding childcare grants

“It is amazing what you can accomplish if you do not care who gets the credit.”

~Harry S Truman